Flash forward to my mid – twenties. I’m parked at 7-11, one foot propped on the dash. The guys in the truck on my left are waving their hands trying to get my attention. But this is a parking lot where I don’t quite belong and logic questions why they are talking to me. I roll down my window and am pleasantly surprised. The guy in the passenger seat smiles and says “Hey, we like your toenails.” I smile, thank him and decide pedicures are a justifiable expense.
________
I am on the phone with a close friend and I am still embarrassed. I have called to ask a specific question which easily lurks beyond my normal conversation. And because I feel stupid asking, I shove in lots of background information before I can manage the actual question. Words sputter quickly through my mouth. “Well, you know how I never dress very nice, and I don’t care and don’t know how to look decent if I tried… well…”
“So you want me to tell you the one thing you could do to look girly? Do you want me to come over there and go on a shopping spree with you?”
“Well, that’s not what I called to ask, but okay tell me the one thing.”
“You should wear earrings. I don’t know if you like gold or silver, but I like hoops because they don’t catch on things. Mine are pretty big, but I’d say for you, a hoop the size, like the cap on a chapstick.”
“Yeah, I am definitely not a gold person. I like silver though. I used to wear earrings. Yeah I am not wearing hoops as big as yours, not that yours don’t look really good, but no way. Okay that is a good suggestion. I can do that.” I attempt to psyche myself up.
“You can do it,” says Tiffany. She is a neat friend, the type who acts as if this conversation is absolutely normal, despite the fact I am babbling as always, but making less sense than usual.
“So let me ask the question I called for. It’s good to know the earring thing though. That’s a good answer. I was going to get a manicure and pedicure but I don’t know what color to get.” That’s the huge mind bending question I called to ask.
She suggests I go with light yellow for my toes. Why? She says it is cute and people will notice, and then if they notice and ask why yellow, I just say, “It’s the color of the season.” Her friend Wendy, definitely the fashion connoisseur, told her this. I know Wendy just well enough to know this is true.
We go on to discuss whether it is a faux paux to paint your fingernails one color, and your toenails another, or if this is okay. She has no idea, which makes me feel slightly better that I am not a complete fashion disaster. I hang up with Susan, grateful for her ability to answer my questions yet leave my pride unharmed.
Part of my irrational fear is the following: If I know something looks decent I wouldn’t have a problem looking decent in it, but I have little confidence in my ability to make this distinction. It is more embarrassing if you admit to putting in the effort to look nice and fail, than if you do not try at all. This attitude is not surprising, as my family has always adhered to the choice of least risk. Better to come away with your dignity than die trying.
Now what is the worst thing that could happen if I put on earrings or got my nails painted? The guys at work would make fun of me. However, as humiliating as this might be, I know it is not a reason that should prevent me from looking a little more girly.
I get in my car and drive until I locate a nail place. They are in every strip mall, but I wonder if I need an appointment or if I can just walk in. I purposely choose a location far away from the nearby uppity neighborhood. No need to be more intimidated than I already am. I try to walk in the door of Happy Nails salon like I have been there before. I enter. Eyes look at me. I suspect I am the only person walking into Happy Nails who is nervous about soaking her feet in a spa, relaxing in a massage chair and having her hands and feet buffed and painted. Not only have I never gotten a manicure and pedicure, but I never wanted one. My across the hall neighbor and impromptu fashion consultant, somewhat dared me, but I knew I could do it.
Happy Nails has a fifteen minute wait. In retrospect I realize I could have used this time to pick out a nail polish color, but I was hungry so I went to Subway for a sandwich. When I return, the other clients are busy reading or chatting and nobody looks at me like I am a freak. Why would I expect this? I am not convinced I am the type of woman who looks as though she belongs here.
The type of woman who is allowed is my friend’s mom Susan. When she yanked me aside at Christmas and told me things I did not want to hear, how I had better start dressing as if I cared how I looked, I was scared and loved at the same time. She stated this topic would be an “ongoing conversation,” and I knew she was not kidding.
Ironically, my actual mother had been attempting this same “ongoing conversation,” with me, throughout my entire life. By junior high, she was a seasoned expert in shopping for clothes that could be a bit girly but were things I might actually wear. When soccer and basketball teams required v-neck or sleeveless jerseys, I always wore a t-shirt underneath. I felt naked in the three-inch triangle below where a normal collar covered, and was horrified at the idea of wearing a sleeveless basketball jersey.
Of course, every year of college provided at least one friend or roommate who desperately threatened to dress me up, curl my hair and force me to wear makeup. I never let them.
Now my feet are in the water, but my nail lady hasn’t turned on the spa, and I am not going to ask. I am still hoping to fade into the chair and vanish before this event concludes. I can handle the foot washing and buffing and I am almost fascinated by the process.
At one point, the nail lady whips out a metal instrument used to shave off dead skin. I’ve seen this in the athletic training room at college. Upon my approval, she goes at the bottom of my heels with the speed of an expert potato peeler. I am expecting her to hit live skin at any moment. I am preparing not to scream. I wonder what she would do if I did scream.
As a child, the dentist would advise me to raise my hand if I felt pain. Clever, but I would have preferred jumping out of the chair. During one filling, he accused me of scaring the other patients by screaming. Well if he had stopped scaring me, I would not have had to scare the other patients.
Back in the massage chair, I have my cell phone on silent, yet find it clenched in my hand.
I realize I should have picked a nail color, but I don’t know how this works. I am having an internal panic about not only what color to choose, but also how stupid I feel that I don’t know what color to choose. I am definitely against fire engine red, and clear polish on my toenails seems like cheating. I am convinced the nail lady will think I am a complete fool because I don’t care what color she paints my nails. Isn’t this the point of the entire process?
As I determine how to answer, I slyly observe the other women, hoping to pick up some procedural tips. I notice everyone dries their toes under a special table and little fans. How long does this take? I should pay attention. I feel like a visitor at church when they are serving communion. Maybe you have taken communion most of your life or maybe never before, but in this church you don’t know when to stand up and sit down, whether to sip from the cup or dip your bread in the wine. You feel like everyone is watching you when you get in the wrong line or drink your little cup of wine before you are supposed to. Yet nobody really tells you what to do.
Soon this nice nail lady will be onto me. She’ll ask what color I want, and I won’t have the answer. And I will have to trust her with the reality of whether I leave looking ridiculous or not. What if I pick a bad color? Will she even tell me?
“Have you been here before?”
”No,” I admit. Now she has found me out. However, she can still assume I have had a manicure before, just not at this exact shop.
However, several minutes later her suspicions are confirmed. “What shape do you want?” she asks, and again I don’t have a normal answer. I do not even know what the choices are.
“What? Uh, whatever you think looks best. I will trust you.” Now she is filing both skin and nail.
At this point, the lady on my right glances over to see what woman is having her nails done, but doesn’t seem to care what they look like. She is reading a book and appears to be relaxed and enjoying her pedicure. She is probably a young housewife, not too fancy and not too plain. Her fingernails are chewed down and shorter than mine are. I don’t even know how people come up with the idea of biting their nails. If she can be here, so can I. Two chairs down an executive woman and her teenage daughter are also getting pedicures. I had hoped someone my age might be getting her nails done. I would strike up a friendly conversation and have some help picking a color. I should have forced a friend to come with me.
When I first walked in I must have been right behind the star customer, a tall late thirties brunette who appeared as though she visited often. She took her place in the first chair like a queen on her throne and a host of manicurists appeared to scrub, buff, and paint. She was clearly the type of woman who belongs here.
“What color do you want?”
I knew this question was coming and I wish I had some smart answer. I didn’t so I told the truth.
“I’m not sure.... nothing too bright, maybe a light purple. I was hoping you could help me.”
“Okay, I will help you.”
She darts over to the front display case and picks out three colors. One is pink and one is old lady mauve, neither of which I would prefer. The third is light purple, which will have to be the right color. She puts it on, and I am half a thought from telling her this will not work. Would I even know if I liked any color on my foot? Probably not. She is quick and I decide the color will be fine once it dries. If not, I can always take it off.
I am feeling good about surviving the foot part when she relocates me to the manicurist table. Again, I covertly study the woman beside me so I know what to do. The television is broadcasting news from her direction so this helps my undercover operation. I notice she has her credit card sitting on the table. I realize I need to take mine out of my pocket as well, because obviously I will not be able to do this once my nails are wet.
The next morning, on my way to work I really do pray nobody makes fun of me … especially the guys. Once a week we have an office staff meeting in which we tend to get bored and stare at each other. Someone is sure to notice my light purple toes and silver earrings. I literally pray that if the guys do make fun of me, I will have a smart comeback, or at the very least, one of the mother co-workers will tell me the color I picked is good. As you recall… I have no idea.
What I least desire to occur is something like the embarrassing fashion blunder I assess last weekend. I am at a street fair downtown, walking behind a middle-aged woman. She is wearing a white tank top that is all I notice, because entangled in her hair is the price tag, still attached on the plastic piece. It is dangling out the back of her shirt and reads something like Old Navy $8.50. Should I get her attention and advise her of this oversight? I decide she has probably been walking around several hours, and for me to tell her now, surely she will be embarrassed. If she goes home later and takes off the shirt, she can still wonder if the tag was sticking out all day. However, she could also assume the tag was tucked in.
I arrive at my job, and a miraculous thing occurs. We have a busy day and none of the guys say anything. One of the women says she likes the color. Okay, now I am glad I chose to wear sandals instead of tennis shoes to hide my toes. (Work is pretty casual dress when you are a soccer coach…) Getting ready for work that morning I had rationalized if I was going to get teased, I should take the heat all at once. All I have to do is act like this is normal for a couple days and then it will be normal.
I feel compelled to report back to a few friends regarding this whole personal experiment. They are thrilled, and say things like: “Who is the guy?” I’m just happy they don’t laugh at me.
“Isn’t a pedicure supposed to be relaxing?” asks one.
“Yeah, but it just wasn’t, because I felt weird being there. You know me.”
“I totally understand. I feel weird going to get my hair cut at the beauty salon.”
“Really? Are you serious?” I ask.
“Yeah, it’s intimidating because I don’t go there very often and it’s so fancy.”
“Really?”
I cannot believe what I am hearing. This conversation comes from a recently married friend who is beautiful, has a handsome husband, always looks nice, and is respected and successful in her line of work. I never imagined her being intimidated by anything related to beauty.
I email Susan, the driving force behind the whole “looking nice is crucial to my social and mental well being.” It is difficult to type when my arms keep crossing due to my resistance. I try to convey the entire event; to explain in fifty words or less that I have cleared this major hurdle, I feel good about it, and she has been huge to encourage me. I tell her that yes, she was right and I am glad she pushed me, but she had better have some patience in the future.

Now I am okay with having my nails painted and wearing earrings, but I still fear the day someone calls me into that cable TV show “What Not to Wear.” The hosts provide the unsuspecting victim with $5,000 and some “rules,” and send them out to shop for better clothes. But first, the fashionably clueless guest has been secretly filmed. This step is so we the audience, can see why he or she has been nominated to receive this windfall of personal shopping assistance. I imagine what they would think if they were to catch me. So on occasion I check over my shoulder to make sure there is no cameraman in the bushes.
I am afraid of being called out, via TV or God himself. I am not comfortable hearing “You are beautiful.” Beautiful is a word tacked to flower arrangements, Mozart concertos and sunsets on the beach. I fall more safely into the framework of athletic or unique, descriptions unrelated to any parts of the female anatomy that guys are attracted to.
I convinced myself I didn’t care. Beauty was for the other girls, the ones that guys liked. Now it has taken much effort by friends and this “ongoing conversation,” to begin undoing the world’s lies. I finally realize I haven’t missed any secret classes on becoming a woman. And I know I am not alone. I know there are other women, in fact most, who question exactly the same things.
I know God is God. I know He knows I am uncomfortable in my own skin… or at least I was. I am making progress. I’ve moved one notch forward on the continuum…gone from being uncomfortable in my skin to being uncomfortable in my clothes. We’ll save that for another chapter…
Labels: beauty, manicure